ASA vs PLA: Which 3D Printing Filament Should You Choose?

Choosing the right 3D printing filament can feel tricky, especially when comparing ASA vs PLA. Both materials are popular, but they serve very different needs. 

In this guide, we will break down everything you need to know so you can make the best choice for your projects. 

Keep reading to discover which filament fits your goals.

What is PLA Filament?

PLA, or Polylactic Acid, is one of the most common filaments used in 3D printing. It is made from renewable resources like corn starch or sugarcane, making it more sustainable than many petroleum-based plastics.

Features of PLA:

• ✅ Prints at lower temperatures without much setup
• ✅ Smooth, glossy surface finish with many color options
• ✅ Minimal warping and no need for an enclosed printer

Best for:

• ✅ Beginners learning 3D printing basics
• ✅ Decorative models, toys, and prototypes
• ✅ Classrooms and home printing setups

Why try it:
PLA is affordable, easy to use, and widely available. While it is sometimes marketed as biodegradable, in reality, PLA only breaks down under industrial composting conditions with high heat and controlled environments, not in home compost bins or landfills. 

This makes it eco-friendlier than most plastics, but it should still be disposed of responsibly.

What is ASA Filament?

ASA, or Acrylonitrile Styrene Acrylate, is a thermoplastic designed for strength and outdoor durability. Unlike PLA, it can handle sunlight, heat, and weather without breaking down.

Features of ASA:

• ✅ Strong, impact-resistant, and long-lasting
• ✅ Excellent UV and heat resistance for outdoor use
• ✅ Matte finish that hides layer lines and can be sanded or painted

Best for:

• ✅ Outdoor parts and functional tools
• ✅ Automotive components and prototypes
• ✅ Projects requiring strength and weather resistance

Why try it:
ASA is tougher than PLA and built to last in challenging environments. If you want prints that can handle real-world use, ASA is a smart choice. 

📌 To explore advanced ASA options, check out Siraya Tech FibreHeat ASA-GF White: The Ultimate 3D Printing Filament for Outdoor and High-Performance Applications.

ASA vs PLA: Side-by-Side Comparison

ASA vs PLA is best understood by looking at their differences in one place. This table highlights strength, durability, ease of use, and more so you can quickly see which filament fits your needs.

When to Use PLA and ASA

Choosing between PLA and ASA depends on the type of project you are working on. PLA is perfect for simple, decorative, or indoor applications, while ASA shines in demanding, outdoor, and functional roles.

✅ Use PLA when:

• You are new to 3D printing and want an easy-to-use filament.
• You are making decorative models, prototypes, or toys.
• You need a low-cost option for classroom or hobby projects.

✅ Use ASA when:

• You need durable parts that can withstand heat, sunlight, or weather.
• You are creating outdoor tools, automotive parts, or functional prototypes.
• You want a professional finish with strong, long-lasting performance.

This simple rule of thumb: choose PLA for learning and indoor projects, and ASA for real-world, outdoor, or high-strength applications.

You May Shop

Printing Tips for ASA and PLA

Printing PLA is simple. It works at lower temperatures, usually does not need a heated bed, and sticks well to many surfaces. 

Beginners can get good results without much effort, making it the easiest material for first-time users.

ASA, however, requires more preparation. To get the best results:

• ✅ Use an enclosed printer to maintain stable temperatures and reduce warping.
• ✅ Apply bed adhesives to improve first-layer sticking.
• ✅ Dry ASA before printing to prevent moisture-related issues.

Taking these extra steps ensures ASA prints come out strong and reliable.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

It is easy to run into problems if you use the wrong material for the wrong job. One common mistake is choosing PLA for outdoor projects. While it is easy to print, it cannot handle heat or sunlight and will lose strength quickly.

Another mistake is printing ASA without proper conditions. To avoid issues:

• ✅ Always use ventilation to reduce exposure to fumes.
• ✅ Prepare the print bed with adhesives to prevent warping.
• ✅ Dry the filament before use for stronger layer bonding.

Planning ahead and setting up your printer correctly will help you avoid these problems and get the most from both filaments.

Conclusion

When comparing ASA vs PLA, the decision comes down to your project needs. PLA is easy, affordable, and great for beginners, while ASA is strong, durable, and perfect for outdoor or functional parts.

For more helpful guides and tips on choosing the right 3D printing filament, visit Siraya. And do not forget to shop Siraya ASA, TPU, PPA, and other high-quality filaments for your next printing project.

Frequently Asked Questions About ASA vs PLA

What is the best thing to print with ASA?

ASA is best for outdoor parts, automotive components, and functional prototypes. It is especially strong in projects that need to resist sunlight, heat, or weather. These qualities make ASA a go-to choice for practical prints.

Does ASA filament give off fumes?

Yes, ASA does release noticeable fumes during printing. Good ventilation or an enclosed printer setup is recommended when working with ASA. This helps keep your workspace safe and comfortable.

Is ASA more brittle than PLA?

No, ASA is generally less brittle than PLA. While PLA can snap under stress, ASA has better impact resistance. This makes it more reliable for functional parts.

Does ASA need bed adhesive?

Yes, bed adhesive can help ASA stick better to the print surface. Without it, ASA is more likely to warp or lift during printing. Many users rely on adhesives like glue sticks or specialized sheets.

Is ASA as strong as PETG?

ASA and PETG are both strong, but they excel in different areas. ASA is more resistant to UV and weather, while PETG is easier to print and has excellent layer adhesion. Choosing between them depends on whether you need outdoor durability or simpler printing.

What kind of glue do you use for ASA prints?

ASA prints can be glued with common plastic adhesives or superglue. Sanding the surfaces before gluing can improve the bond. Some users also use solvents for stronger chemical welding.